24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with Progress Game's. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Inventory Management, Character Customization, Magic, RPG, Resource Management, Medieval.

1·Mini Healer
76% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
87% of 2,327 reviews positive

2·Fantasy Blacksmith
76% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
48% of 1,817 reviews positive

3·App 568780
76% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
74% of 34 reviews positive

4·Grocery Store Simulator
76% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
91% of 6,190 reviews positive

5·Chef Life: A Restaurant Simulator
73% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
84% of 2,805 reviews positive

6·Tiny Rails
73% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
73% of 730 reviews positive

7·Megaloot
73% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
72% of 4,010 reviews positive

8·Two Worlds II HD
72% match · Inventory Management, RPG
64% of 7,033 reviews positive

9·Drug Dealer Simulator 2
71% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
70% of 5,933 reviews positive

10·Grim Clicker
71% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
78% of 2,889 reviews positive

11·Superfuse
70% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
38% of 1,060 reviews positive

12·Sephiria
70% match · Inventory Management, Fantasy
94% of 12,794 reviews positive

13·Hogwarts Legacy
70% match · Magic, Character Customization
90% of 374,043 reviews positive · 10,367 playing

14·God Of Weapons
69% match · Inventory Management, Stylized
84% of 5,253 reviews positive

15·Infinite Dungeon Crawler
69% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
55% of 47 reviews positive

16·Save Room - Organization Puzzle
69% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
97% of 2,492 reviews positive

17·Hammerting
69% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
57% of 2,603 reviews positive

18·The Adventurers
69% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
79% of 151 reviews positive

19·Starsand
68% match · Inventory Management, Resource Management
66% of 1,267 reviews positive

20·Orb of Creation
68% match · Resource Management, Magic
84% of 2,234 reviews positive

21·Barn Finders: The Pilot
68% match · Inventory Management, Casual
92% of 499 reviews positive

22·Bound By Flame
68% match · RPG, Demons
68% of 4,050 reviews positive

23·Home Behind 2
68% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
87% of 7,248 reviews positive

24·Stoneshard: Prologue
68% match · Inventory Management, Character Customization
87% of 3,557 reviews positive
The closest matches to Progress Game on Steam are Mini Healer, Fantasy Blacksmith, App 568780, Grocery Store Simulator, Chef Life: A Restaurant Simulator. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with Progress Game's, and shared tags include Inventory Management, Character Customization, Magic.
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Inventory Management, Character Customization, Magic count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches Progress Game's. Popularity never affects the ranking.