24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with The Lamplighters League's. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Tactical RPG, Alternate History, Strategy RPG, Turn-Based Combat, Multiple Endings, Choices Matter.

1·Pathway
79% match · Tactical RPG, Alternate History
77% of 2,263 reviews positive

2·Legends of Eisenwald
78% match · Tactical RPG, Strategy RPG
76% of 1,832 reviews positive

3·Ash of Gods: Redemption
77% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
74% of 3,474 reviews positive

4·The Banner Saga 3
77% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
79% of 3,107 reviews positive

5·Blackguards 2
77% match · Turn-Based Combat, Tactical RPG
67% of 1,313 reviews positive

6·Disciples: Liberation
76% match · Tactical RPG, Dark Fantasy
73% of 3,991 reviews positive

7·The Last Spell
76% match · Tactical RPG, Strategy RPG
91% of 13,748 reviews positive

8·Warhammer 40,000: Chaos Gate - Daemonhunters
76% match · Strategy RPG, Turn-Based Strategy
77% of 14,797 reviews positive

9·Jagged Alliance 3
76% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
89% of 14,916 reviews positive

10·Fell Seal: Arbiter's Mark
76% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
88% of 6,368 reviews positive

11·Dark Deity
75% match · Tactical RPG, Strategy RPG
72% of 3,115 reviews positive

12·King Arthur: Knight's Tale
75% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
84% of 7,555 reviews positive

13·Hard West 2
75% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Strategy
82% of 3,228 reviews positive

14·Tears of Avia
75% match · Tactical RPG, Cinematic
50% of 104 reviews positive

15·King's Bounty II
75% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Strategy
62% of 5,539 reviews positive

16·The Banner Saga 2
75% match · Turn-Based Strategy, Choices Matter
90% of 3,806 reviews positive

17·The Age of Decadence
74% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
82% of 4,061 reviews positive · 23 playing

18·Vendir: Plague of Lies
74% match · Tactical RPG, Turn-Based Combat
75% of 267 reviews positive

19·Weird West: Definitive Edition
74% match · Tactical RPG, Supernatural
78% of 4,499 reviews positive

20·Halcyon 6: Starbase Commander
73% match · Turn-Based Combat, Strategy RPG
84% of 1,321 reviews positive

21·App 1437010
73% match · Tactical RPG, Strategy RPG
96% of 252 reviews positive

22·King's Bounty: Warriors of the North
73% match · Turn-Based Strategy, Strategy RPG
79% of 2,068 reviews positive · 133 playing

23·Tactics Ogre: Reborn
73% match · Tactical RPG, Strategy RPG
73% of 4,621 reviews positive

24·Jagged Alliance: Rage!
73% match · Tactical RPG, Strategy RPG
51% of 506 reviews positive
The closest matches to The Lamplighters League on Steam are Pathway, Legends of Eisenwald, Ash of Gods: Redemption, The Banner Saga 3, Blackguards 2. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with The Lamplighters League's, and shared tags include Tactical RPG, Alternate History, Strategy RPG.
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Tactical RPG, Alternate History, Strategy RPG count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches The Lamplighters League's. Popularity never affects the ranking.