24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with Was It Worth It?'s. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Walking Simulator, Multiple Endings, Choices Matter, Comedy, Surreal, Exploration.

1·The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe
87% match · Walking Simulator, Multiple Endings
94% of 36,243 reviews positive

2·The Old City: Leviathan
85% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
72% of 745 reviews positive

3·MIND: Path to Thalamus Enhanced Edition
82% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
66% of 1,427 reviews positive

4·Obduction
81% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
80% of 3,998 reviews positive

5·Everybody's Gone to the Rapture
81% match · Walking Simulator, Exploration
67% of 2,165 reviews positive

6·Mondealy
81% match · Walking Simulator, Multiple Endings
94% of 651 reviews positive

7·Broken Reality
80% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
92% of 2,320 reviews positive

8·The Next Door
80% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
49% of 1,116 reviews positive

9·Mitoza
80% match · Surreal, Choices Matter
96% of 3,922 reviews positive

10·Firewatch
80% match · Walking Simulator, Mystery
91% of 99,619 reviews positive · 127 playing

11·Submerged
79% match · Walking Simulator, Nature
76% of 4,857 reviews positive

12·Dear Esther
79% match · Walking Simulator, Exploration
76% of 6,120 reviews positive

13·Cloud Climber
79% match · Walking Simulator, Post-apocalyptic
92% of 4,157 reviews positive

14·Siren Head: Awakening
79% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
73% of 966 reviews positive

15·Riven
79% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
92% of 2,892 reviews positive

16·Off-Peak
78% match · Walking Simulator, Surreal
89% of 1,848 reviews positive

17·Depanneur Nocturne
78% match · Surreal, Multiple Endings
96% of 259 reviews positive

18·Gone In November
78% match · Walking Simulator, First-Person
63% of 401 reviews positive

19·The Fidelio Incident
78% match · Walking Simulator, Mystery
78% of 849 reviews positive

20·INFRA
78% match · Walking Simulator, Exploration
88% of 3,756 reviews positive

21·Ether One
78% match · Walking Simulator, Exploration
73% of 452 reviews positive

22·Dream
78% match · Walking Simulator, Exploration
56% of 997 reviews positive

23·1000xRESIST
77% match · Walking Simulator, Futuristic
94% of 7,084 reviews positive

24·While We Wait Here
77% match · Walking Simulator, Multiple Endings
89% of 2,478 reviews positive
The closest matches to Was It Worth It? on Steam are The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe, The Old City: Leviathan, MIND: Path to Thalamus Enhanced Edition, Obduction, Everybody's Gone to the Rapture. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with Was It Worth It?'s, and shared tags include Walking Simulator, Multiple Endings, Choices Matter.
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Walking Simulator, Multiple Endings, Choices Matter count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches Was It Worth It?'s. Popularity never affects the ranking.