1.0·Every feature free until Premium arrives in October
Games like Scarlet Hollow
24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with Scarlet Hollow's. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Well-Written, Visual Novel, Supernatural, Psychological Horror, Narrative, Lovecraftian.
Closest first
1·Urban Myth Dissolution Center
83% match · Well-Written, Visual Novel
88% of 6,381 reviews positive
2·Midnight Scenes: The Goodbye Note
81% match · Well-Written, Narrative
97% of 158 reviews positive
3·OXENFREE II: Lost Signals
81% match · Narrative, Supernatural
88% of 2,080 reviews positive
4·TASOKARE HOTEL Re:newal
80% match · Well-Written, Visual Novel
87% of 82 reviews positive
5·PARANORMASIGHT: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo
79% match · Well-Written, Supernatural
95% of 7,347 reviews positive
6·App 1406040
78% match · Supernatural, Interactive Fiction
96% of 703 reviews positive
7·The Casting of Frank Stone™
78% match · Choices Matter, Lovecraftian
62% of 6,030 reviews positive
8·Sucker for Love: First Date
78% match · Lovecraftian, Dating Sim
98% of 3,030 reviews positive
9·Cabernet
78% match · Dating Sim, Choices Matter
95% of 2,386 reviews positive
10·Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
77% match · Visual Novel, Dating Sim
97% of 34,555 reviews positive
11·Sally Face - Episode One
77% match · Narrative, Supernatural
97% of 29,935 reviews positive
12·Wild Island Quest
77% match · Interactive Fiction, Visual Novel
53% of 344 reviews positive
13·BAD END
77% match · Visual Novel, Interactive Fiction
83% of 397 reviews positive
14·Afterparty
77% match · Narrative, Supernatural
68% of 967 reviews positive
15·Saint Kotar
77% match · Lovecraftian, Interactive Fiction
74% of 295 reviews positive
16·Sucker for Love: Date to Die For
76% match · Dating Sim, Lovecraftian
95% of 1,359 reviews positive
17·Extra Case: My Girlfriend's Secrets
76% match · Dating Sim, Lovecraftian
85% of 184 reviews positive
18·Elisa: Seduce the Innkeeper
76% match · Dating Sim, Interactive Fiction
72% of 191 reviews positive
19·Border of her Heart
76% match · Dating Sim, Interactive Fiction
67% of 73 reviews positive
20·Heaven's Vault
75% match · Narrative, Interactive Fiction
84% of 2,501 reviews positive
21·Corpse Party (2021)
75% match · Supernatural, Choices Matter
90% of 1,546 reviews positive
22·Oxenfree
75% match · Supernatural, Choices Matter
91% of 12,125 reviews positive
23·Little Misfortune
75% match · Choices Matter, Psychological Horror
92% of 14,209 reviews positive
24·The Letter - Horror Visual Novel
75% match · Visual Novel, Choices Matter
85% of 1,535 reviews positive
Frequently asked
What games are similar to Scarlet Hollow?
The closest matches to Scarlet Hollow on Steam are Urban Myth Dissolution Center, Midnight Scenes: The Goodbye Note, OXENFREE II: Lost Signals, TASOKARE HOTEL Re:newal, PARANORMASIGHT: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with Scarlet Hollow's, and shared tags include Well-Written, Visual Novel, Supernatural.
How are games like Scarlet Hollow chosen?
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Well-Written, Visual Novel, Supernatural count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches Scarlet Hollow's. Popularity never affects the ranking.