24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with Bloomtown: A Different Story's. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG, JRPG, Cute, Lore-Rich, Turn-Based Tactics.

1·Digimon World: Next Order
84% match · Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG
81% of 2,997 reviews positive

2·World Zero
79% match · Party-Based RPG, Lore-Rich
90% of 39 reviews positive

3·Kitchen Simulator 2015
78% match · Cooking, Time Management
40% of 330 reviews positive

4·Nuumonsters
77% match · Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG
61% of 71 reviews positive

5·Ni no Kuni Wrath of the White Witch™ Remastered
77% match · Creature Collector, JRPG
83% of 5,175 reviews positive

6·Monster Sanctuary
77% match · Creature Collector, Turn-Based Tactics
91% of 12,707 reviews positive

7·Visions of Mana
77% match · Party-Based RPG, JRPG
78% of 2,755 reviews positive

8·Atelier Rorona ~The Alchemist of Arland~ DX
77% match · JRPG, Time Management
92% of 774 reviews positive

9·FINAL FANTASY IV
76% match · Party-Based RPG, Lore-Rich
92% of 3,079 reviews positive

10·Athenian Rhapsody
76% match · Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG
90% of 370 reviews positive

11·Portal Fantasy
76% match · Creature Collector, Turn-Based Tactics
66% of 258 reviews positive

12·WORLD OF FINAL FANTASY®
76% match · Creature Collector, JRPG
76% of 3,383 reviews positive

13·Shawarma Legend
75% match · Cooking, Time Management
92% of 7,787 reviews positive

14·Empire Chronicles
75% match · Party-Based RPG, Lore-Rich
94% of 31 reviews positive

15·Elohim Eternal: The Babel Code
75% match · Party-Based RPG, Lore-Rich
94% of 51 reviews positive

16·Fae Tactics
75% match · Turn-Based Tactics, Creature Collector
85% of 1,755 reviews positive

17·Sea of Stars: Sunset Edition
74% match · Party-Based RPG, JRPG
88% of 15,624 reviews positive

18·Atelier Firis: The Alchemist and the Mysterious Journey DX
74% match · JRPG, Lore-Rich
74% of 494 reviews positive

19·Nexomon
74% match · Creature Collector, RPG
89% of 1,842 reviews positive

20·Shin Megami Tensei III Nocturne HD Remaster
74% match · Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG
87% of 5,302 reviews positive

21·Ooblets
74% match · Creature Collector, Cooking
91% of 1,557 reviews positive

22·Atelier Sophie: The Alchemist of the Mysterious Book DX
74% match · JRPG, Female Protagonist
90% of 1,052 reviews positive

23·Coromon
74% match · Creature Collector, JRPG
84% of 8,103 reviews positive

24·Wolf's Gang
74% match · Party-Based RPG, JRPG
93% of 150 reviews positive
The closest matches to Bloomtown: A Different Story on Steam are Digimon World: Next Order, World Zero, Kitchen Simulator 2015, Nuumonsters, Ni no Kuni Wrath of the White Witch™ Remastered. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with Bloomtown: A Different Story's, and shared tags include Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG, JRPG.
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Creature Collector, Party-Based RPG, JRPG count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches Bloomtown: A Different Story's. Popularity never affects the ranking.