24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with Hack, Slash, Loot's. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like, RPG, Turn-Based, Perma Death, Dungeon Crawler.

1·Rogue's Tale
99% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
72% of 756 reviews positive

2·Dungeons of Dredmor
99% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
94% of 5,442 reviews positive

3·Dungeonmans
99% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
91% of 1,237 reviews positive

4·Tales of Maj'Eyal
95% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
94% of 7,490 reviews positive

5·Shattered Pixel Dungeon
87% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
95% of 2,213 reviews positive

6·Wayward
86% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
86% of 1,368 reviews positive

7·Quest of Dungeons
85% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
76% of 737 reviews positive

8·One Way Heroics
84% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
94% of 4,162 reviews positive

9·Shiren the Wanderer: The Tower of Fortune and the Dice of Fate
84% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
76% of 956 reviews positive

10·Sproggiwood
83% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
80% of 595 reviews positive

11·UnReal World
82% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
94% of 1,386 reviews positive

12·Elin
82% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
93% of 9,256 reviews positive

13·Shattered Planet
81% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
68% of 661 reviews positive

14·Sword of the Stars: The Pit
81% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
83% of 1,555 reviews positive

15·Fate Seeker: Journey
81% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
78% of 1,204 reviews positive

16·Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead
81% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
87% of 550 reviews positive

17·Prime of Flames
81% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
85% of 1,024 reviews positive

18·Hydra Slayer
80% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
92% of 49 reviews positive

19·HyperRogue
79% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
96% of 497 reviews positive

20·Mainframe Defenders
78% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
88% of 796 reviews positive

21·Rift Wizard
78% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
92% of 1,064 reviews positive

22·Endgame of Devil
77% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
89% of 1,043 reviews positive

23·Endorlight
75% match · Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like
60% of 1,410 reviews positive

24·Desktop Dungeons
75% match · Rogue-like, Traditional Roguelike
84% of 2,364 reviews positive
The closest matches to Hack, Slash, Loot on Steam are Rogue's Tale, Dungeons of Dredmor, Dungeonmans, Tales of Maj'Eyal, Shattered Pixel Dungeon. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with Hack, Slash, Loot's, and shared tags include Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like, RPG.
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Traditional Roguelike, Rogue-like, RPG count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches Hack, Slash, Loot's. Popularity never affects the ranking.