24 games ranked by how much the tags Steam players vote on them overlap with Wild Island Quest's. A rare tag counts for far more than one that sits on half the store, and popularity never moves a game up.
What they share most: Interactive Fiction, Choices Matter, Choose Your Own Adventure, Visual Novel, Multiple Endings.

1·The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante
92% match · Interactive Fiction, Choices Matter
88% of 13,174 reviews positive

2·80 Days
92% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Interactive Fiction
90% of 2,040 reviews positive

3·The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series
90% match · Interactive Fiction, Choices Matter
97% of 47,486 reviews positive

4·I Wani Hug that Gator!
88% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
98% of 5,768 reviews positive

5·Star Trek: Resurgence
88% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
89% of 3,173 reviews positive

6·Sorcery! Parts 1 and 2
88% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Interactive Fiction
88% of 762 reviews positive

7·Soul Gambler
87% match · Visual Novel, Choices Matter
87% of 2,724 reviews positive

8·The Bottom of the Well
87% match · Visual Novel, Choose Your Own Adventure
85% of 592 reviews positive

9·Road 96: Mile 0
86% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
68% of 2,159 reviews positive

10·Stories from Sol: The Gun-Dog
85% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
91% of 963 reviews positive

11·The NOexistenceN of you AND me
85% match · Interactive Fiction, Visual Novel
93% of 22,390 reviews positive

12·The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante — Chapter 1&2
85% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
96% of 2,039 reviews positive

13·App 1406040
85% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Interactive Fiction
96% of 703 reviews positive

14·Five Dates
84% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
85% of 2,838 reviews positive

15·BAD END THEATER
84% match · Visual Novel, Choose Your Own Adventure
97% of 10,086 reviews positive

16·Refind Self: The Personality Test Game
84% match · Interactive Fiction, Visual Novel
88% of 3,803 reviews positive

17·I Was a Teenage Exocolonist
83% match · Interactive Fiction, Choose Your Own Adventure
96% of 4,859 reviews positive

18·Far Away
83% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Interactive Fiction
95% of 8,201 reviews positive

19·While We Wait Here
83% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Multiple Endings
89% of 2,478 reviews positive

20·Bloodshore
83% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Visual Novel
69% of 972 reviews positive

21·Monster Loves You!
83% match · Choose Your Own Adventure, Multiple Endings
78% of 1,197 reviews positive

22·Love, Money, Rock'n'Roll
83% match · Visual Novel, Interactive Fiction
79% of 7,149 reviews positive

23·The Letter - Horror Visual Novel
83% match · Visual Novel, Choices Matter
85% of 1,535 reviews positive

24·Emily is Away
83% match · Interactive Fiction, Choices Matter
89% of 32,332 reviews positive
The closest matches to Wild Island Quest on Steam are The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante, 80 Days, The Walking Dead: The Telltale Definitive Series, I Wani Hug that Gator!, Star Trek: Resurgence. They rank highest because their Steam community tags overlap most with Wild Island Quest's, and shared tags include Interactive Fiction, Choices Matter, Choose Your Own Adventure.
Every game is described by the tags Steam players vote on it. Rare, specific tags such as Interactive Fiction, Choices Matter, Choose Your Own Adventure count far more than catch-all ones like "Indie" or "Singleplayer", and each game is scored on how closely its whole tag profile matches Wild Island Quest's. Popularity never affects the ranking.