The best-selling Steam games of 2011.
Games released on Steam in 2011, ranked by how many copies they have sold there since. Valve publishes no sales figures; these are Coilr's estimates from each game's reviews.
49 games, most copies first

1·Terraria
44M copies · 2011

2·Portal 2
11M copies · 2011

3·The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
9.1M copies · 2011

4·Saints Row: The Third
3.7M copies · 2011

5·PAYDAY™ The Heist
2.6M copies · 2011

6·Red Orchestra 2: Heroes of Stalingrad with Rising Storm
2.4M copies · 2011

7·Total War: SHOGUN 2
2.3M copies · 2011

8·Magicka
2.1M copies · 2011

9·The Binding of Isaac
2M copies · 2011

10·Mafia II (Classic)
2M copies · 2011

11·LIMBO
2M copies · 2011

12·Assassin’s Creed® Brotherhood
1.7M copies · 2011

13·Call of Duty®: Modern Warfare® 3 (2011)
1.5M copies · 2011

14·Call of Duty®: Modern Warfare® 3 (2011)
1.5M copies · 2011

15·Assassin's Creed® Revelations
1.4M copies · 2011

16·Bastion
1.4M copies · 2011

17·RAGE
1.4M copies · 2011

18·Dungeon Defenders
1.3M copies · 2011

19·Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine - Anniversary Edition
1.3M copies · 2011

20·The Sims™ 3
1.3M copies · 2011

21·Homefront
1.2M copies · 2011

22·Anno 2070™
1.2M copies · 2011

23·F.E.A.R. 3
1.2M copies · 2011

24·Serious Sam 3: BFE
1.1M copies · 2011

Dino D-Day

Alice: Madness Returns

Dead Space™ 2

Duke Nukem Forever

L.A. Noire

Might & Magic: Heroes VI

Mount & Blade: With Fire & Sword

Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance

Two Worlds II HD

Sonic Adventure DX

E.Y.E: Divine Cybermancy

LEGO® Star Wars™ III - The Clone Wars™

Max Payne

Crysis 2 - Maximum Edition

Tropico 4

Arma: Cold War Assault Remastered

Worms Ultimate Mayhem

Men of War: Assault Squad

Orcs Must Die!

Cave Story+

Fable - The Lost Chapters

The Tiny Bang Story

Dungeons of Dredmor

SpaceChem

Syberia
Copies sold on Steam only, estimated from each game's Steam reviews, weighted by when they were written, how big the game is and who plays it (co-op games and story games differ most). Checked against 170 games whose developers announced their sales, the median estimate was 30% off. Free-to-play games are not ranked: their “owners” are everyone who pressed Play once. Neither are adult games, software, or games Steam no longer sells on their own (Grand Theft Auto V Legacy is the biggest): without a price there is no telling a delisted paid game from a closed free one.